top of page

Cold Market Prospecting: What Works, What Doesn't, and How to Get Started

Contrary to what some professionals in the digital marketing industry may believe, cold market prospecting is not a dead-end strategy or lost art. Many B2B statistics show that 82% of buyers are willing to schedule a meeting based on a cold email or cold call alone.

Cold market prospecting can be an incredibly effective way to generate new leads and grow your small business—if you do it right. In this blog from our experts at The Mad Caddy, we'll look at why cold market prospecting is worth your time.

In this blog, our team will also:

  • Discuss what cold market prospecting is and how it works

  • Offer tips on what not to do with cold market prospecting

  • Provide tricks for cold market prospecting success

Cold Market Prospecting

Table of Contents:

  1. Cold Market Prospecting 101

  2. How Does Cold Market Prospecting Work?

  3. Cold Market Prospecting: What Not to Do

  4. 9 Steps for Cold Market Prospecting Success

  5. Define Your Target Market

  6. Research Your Prospects

  7. Research Your Competition

  8. Identify Your Goals

  9. Develop a Strategy

  10. Create A Script

  11. Get Personal

  12. Be Prepared for Objections

  13. Always be Respectful

  14. Conclusion

People Also Ask:

How do you prospect a cold market?

You build relationships with people by talking to them, complimenting them, and exchanging contact information. Then you follow up regularly and set up more opportunities to meet.

When prospecting a cold market, the most important thing is to build trust with potential customers instead of trying to sell to them immediately.

What does cold prospecting mean?

You'll never reach potential customers looking for what you have to offer if you wait for leads to come to you. You can find new opportunities for generating leads and improving sales with cold prospecting.

What is a cold market in business?

The term "cold market" refers to a salesperson's potential future customers. A warm market is the opposite of a cold market.

Marketing to people you know, such as friends/relatives/referrals or existing clients, is a warm market in sales and direct marketing.

Cold Market Prospecting 101

First things first: what is cold market prospecting? In short, it's the process of reaching out to potential customers who don't already have a relationship with your brand.

The goal is always to start a conversation with someone who might need your product or service.

How Does Cold Market Prospecting Work?

At its core, cold market prospecting works by building relationships with potential customers who don't already have a relationship with your brand.

You can do this in many ways, but some of the most effective methods include:

  • Personalized emails

  • LinkedIn messages

  • Attending industry events

  • Picking up the phone and giving people a call

Whichever method you choose, making initial contact in a way that is respectful and non-intrusive is vital.

Cold Market Prospecting: What Not to Do

Now that you know a little bit more about cold market prospecting, it's time to talk about what not to do. Remember, the goal is to start a conversation with someone who might need your product or service.

With that in mind, here's what not to do when cold market prospecting:

Don't be rude or pushy. No one wants to be sold to, so don't try to sell your product or service too hard. Instead, focus on starting a conversation and building a relationship.

Don't be spammy. Sending mass emails or LinkedIn messages is a surefire way to turn people off. Personalize your outreach so that it feels like you're genuinely interested in connecting with the person you're reaching out to.

Don't be afraid to follow up. If someone doesn't respond to your initial outreach, it's okay to follow up once or twice. Just don't be a pest!

9 Steps for Cold Market Prospecting Success

Cold market prospecting can be a great way to reach new customers and grow your business when you do so correctly. We at The Mad Caddy put together a list of nine steps to successful cold market prospecting.

Continue reading to learn more!

Define Your Target Market

The first step in any successful marketing campaign is to identify your target market. What type of customer are you looking for? What needs or pain points do they have that your product or service can address?

Once you understand your ideal customer, you'll be able to target them more effectively with your marketing efforts.

Research Your Prospects

Before you reach out to any potential customers, otherwise known as prospects, you should do your research. A little homework can go a long way in ensuring that your cold market prospecting efforts are successful.

Spend time looking at your target market's website, social media profiles, and any other online presence they might have. This will give you a good idea of their interests and how best to approach them.

Now that you know your target market, it's time to start researching individual prospects. There are several ways to do this, but one of the easiest is searching for them on social media platforms like LinkedIn or Twitter. You can also use Google to search for potential customers in your industry or geographic region.

Once you've found some prospective customers, take some time to discover their individual needs and pain points. This will give you valuable insight into how you can position your product or service in a way that resonates with them.

Research Your Competition

Once you know who you're trying to reach, it's time to research your competition. What are they doing that's working? What could they be doing better? This research will help you fine-tune your marketing strategy to differentiate yourself from the competition.

Identify Your Goals

Now that you've done your research, it's time to set some goals and determine what you want from your cold market prospecting campaign. What do you want to accomplish with your cold market prospecting efforts? Make new sales? Increase brand awareness? Are you looking to generate new leads?

Whatever your goals, they should be achievable, relevant, specific, and measurable. Determining precisely what you wish to accomplish with your campaign means you'll be able to create a more targeted and effective marketing strategy.

Develop a Strategy

Once you've determined your goals, it's time to plan your cold market prospecting strategy. What type of content will you create? What platforms will you use to reach your target market? How often will you reach out to prospects? Answering these questions will help you develop a comprehensive plan for your cold market prospecting efforts.

There are many ways to approach cold market prospecting, but email marketing is one of the most effective. Email allows you to reach a large number of potential customers with minimal effort. And if done correctly, it can be an extremely effective way to generate new leads and sales.

Create A Script

You cannot conduct a successful cold market prospecting campaign without having a script. This doesn't mean that you need to memorize lines verbatim, but rather have an understanding of what points you want to hit.

Your cold email or cold call script should introduce who you are, what your company does, and why the prospect should care. It should be short, sweet, and to the point; You don't want to waste the prospect's time or come across as pushy.

Get Personal

Regardless of cold calling or cold emailing, it's important to remember that you're reaching out to another human being. To build rapport, it helps to personalize your emails by referring to something in their LinkedIn profile or research you've done on the company.

Be Prepared for Objections

One of the most common objections prospects give is that they're not interested. Other objections might include that they're too busy or not the decision maker. It's important to anticipate these objections in advance and have responses ready.

By being prepared for objections, you'll sound confident and stay one step ahead of the prospect.

Always be Respectful

Once you've made your pitch and addressed any objections, thank the prospect for their time and let them know you'll follow up. It is essential to get permission before adding them to your email list or sending additional information.

For example, "Would it be okay if I sent you more information about our product?" If the prospect says no, respect their wishes and don't continue to try to sell them.

By following these tips, you'll be on your way to successful cold market prospecting.

Remember to be prepared, personalize your calls, and always respect the prospect's wishes.


Even if you're comfortable taking risks and making decisions on the fly, there is one area where you can't afford to wing it: sales. To grow your business, you must proactively seek out new customers and market them effectively.

And while there are many ways to find potential customers, cold market prospecting is still one of the most effective. It allows you to get your message in front of people who are already interested in what you're selling.

Contact The Mad Caddy to learn more about how we can help your business with our cold market prospecting services!

Helpful resources

At The Mad Caddy, we strive to be your one-stop shop for valuable insight into all things digital marketing and beyond. Check out the following resources for more information on cold market prospecting!

Websites to Check Out

Social Media Channels



bottom of page